Improve YouTube! (Open-Source for YouTube) のレビュー
Improve YouTube! (Open-Source for YouTube) 作成者: code-for-charity、 ImprovedTube
Firefox ユーザー 19242234 によるレビュー
5 段階中 1 の評価
Firefox ユーザー 19242234 によるレビュー (3ヶ月前)This addon claims there are filter rules. There are no filter rules that I could see. Searching the menu for "filter" reveals nothing. At best, you can "block" channels and videos, a feature youtube already has.
Also, installing this caused all of my firefox tabs on youtube to stop responding, forcing me to close and reopen each.
It's weird to me how strongly they are marketing this addon, too, and the uninstall page vaguely tries to guilt trip you for removing the plugin. I realize this is recommended by mozilla, but it's tripping a lot of sus metrics for me, and I can't recommend it.
Edit: Further review of the developer's responses on low scoring reviews make me even more certain this isn't a good idea. 1) The developers respond to claims the plugin slows users' browser down with "nuh uh no it doesn't" and "yeah well why don't you measure the milliseconds with dev tools?", and 2) The devs claim that voting less than 5 stars is "voting against the project". Why does that matter? Why does your score on your open source, free project matter? It's almost like you're pushing for popularity on your plugin for some other reason. It's incredibly suspicious, and that type of language is couched in incredibly manipulative undertones. *Don't install this.* This thing is full of red flags.
Also, installing this caused all of my firefox tabs on youtube to stop responding, forcing me to close and reopen each.
It's weird to me how strongly they are marketing this addon, too, and the uninstall page vaguely tries to guilt trip you for removing the plugin. I realize this is recommended by mozilla, but it's tripping a lot of sus metrics for me, and I can't recommend it.
Edit: Further review of the developer's responses on low scoring reviews make me even more certain this isn't a good idea. 1) The developers respond to claims the plugin slows users' browser down with "nuh uh no it doesn't" and "yeah well why don't you measure the milliseconds with dev tools?", and 2) The devs claim that voting less than 5 stars is "voting against the project". Why does that matter? Why does your score on your open source, free project matter? It's almost like you're pushing for popularity on your plugin for some other reason. It's incredibly suspicious, and that type of language is couched in incredibly manipulative undertones. *Don't install this.* This thing is full of red flags.
開発者の返信
投稿日時: 2ヶ月前Hi, the word filter applies to our many layout and display:none features. However content-filtering can be the biggest roadmap item since we have not implemented or been asked, most of it. You can read up on it here https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22Filtering%20%26%20Discovery%20(of%20Content)%22 )(half of which remains monologues with no user participation) https://github.com/MarcGuiselin/youtube-refined did some, yet only found about 1000 users then. Recently our new "competitor" Untrap has some too i think and is surprisingly the most / only likely developer to be reading our repo and roadmap. (If you can, suggest them not to collab / not reinvent this difficult task https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/discussions/1881). You can give fair feedback and you might not want to frustrate volunteers. We could also flag this ("Misplaced bug report or support request"), but prefer to keep information visible. There is no marketing budget and usually that would leave traces. When driven by suspicion, you might have more fun /success examining code. (You could enhance global security scanners or run your own).
合計レビュー数: 800
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 18755129 によるレビュー (3時間前)I use this add-on primarily for removing shorts from Youtube. It works perfectly and saves me from brainrot. Soon after Youtube added the AI descriptions, an absolute disgrace of a feature, this add-on added the option to remove them too. Amazing work!
- I just want a button to reverse a playlist. It's great when it works, but most of the time it just does not show up even though it's absolutely checked in the settings (other stuff works fine, I can change the themes easily, but the entire playlist section just does nothing)
- 5 段階中 4 の評価Firefox ユーザー 17661354 によるレビュー (4日前)With this extension you still can't like or dislike a song on youtube music website with any other window in focus. It's 2025. Youtube music website is 10 years old and you still have to alt tab and manually point and click like/dislike button. Unbelievable.
- I want to like this extension so badly. It seems so promising. It's free and made by volunteers and open source.
But I've been trying it off and on for months now, and during that time I've tried it on 4 different browsers and 3 different operating systems (two desktop, one mobile), and it's always broken in multiple ways, and it always absolutely murders Firefox's performance.
Yes, I tried disabling other youtube and adblock extensions. And I tried running Improve Youtube alone and in private mode, with no other extensions. No dice.
And no, my computer is not a potato (nor is my phone). And this is the only addon that's been causing me problems like this.
This extension is just extremely broken, all the time, always. It feels like a super early alpha release, not a finished addon.
You can report issues on github, but even *if* that leads to the issue getting fixed in a halfway timely manner, there are always additional issues occuring at the same time.
There's no predicting which options in the settings menu will work, or which will break even more things, and seemingly aaaaaaall of them tank the browser's performance.
I genuinely don't understand how this addon is getting good reviews. I can imagine it might become an incredible addon eventually, if the tsunami of problems is ever overcome, and I really hope it does, but for right now... Don't waste your time, like I did. There are alternatives to this addon that actually work, and reliably so.
I'd only recommend installing this addon if you're wanting to get involved in developing it, by way of a hobby project. - 5 段階中 4 の評価Firefox ユーザー 15037318 によるレビュー (8日前)Could you add the following features:
1) an option to save the various options selected. So that we can easily import these chosen saved options back again whenever we want.
2) Add a stop button to stop the video at its very start. Sometimes it is useful to check again what was the original starting image of the video. Or when you want to repeat from the very start.
3) In the theater mode, there is an extremely annoying "More videos" option that appears and it is impossible to see below this "More videos" option the comments.
Add an option to get rid completely of this "More videos" option in this theater mode and replace it by allowing instead to be able to see the comments normally instead of this very annoying "More videos" set of video links.
4) Below the description, there is now (sometimes but not always) a summary section that is created automatically. Allow us to chose, for this summary section, the option expanded like it is available also for the Description.
One issue:
Under the section Player, Pause while I watch a 2nd video. It does not work if you watch a 2nd video that is a short video; in such a case, the first video will NOT pause while the second short video will keep running and the sound of the first video will interfere with the sound of the second short video!
Thanks to the developer for this addon. - The extension offers a lot of useful features, but it severely affected my Firefox performance immediately after installation. The browser became noticeably slower, and C.P.U. usage spiked by ~35%. From what I’ve seen in other reviews, the developer tends to dismiss, and deny these performance issues rather than investigating, or assisting affected users; replying with responses in denial, instead of looking into the issue. Unfortunately, due to these problems and the lack of constructive support, I cannot recommend this extension.
- 5 段階中 4 の評価Firefox ユーザー 19217864 によるレビュー (14日前)Abandoned by Enhancer (for YouTube) and, looking for a replacement, switched to this one. I hardly miss Enhancer at all. The only thing I really miss in the change of extension is the comments of youtube, sorted by most recent by default. It seems to me that this extension can't do that. Other than that, everything looks great.
- 5 段階中 3 の評価Firefox ユーザー 14188159 によるレビュー (15日前)It has some nice options and settings possibilities. But unfortunately, some things do not work properly and my browser (Librefox on Linux) becomes completely overloaded, to the point where it even suggests deactivating the add-on! This has happened several times now and is therefore not usable for me.
- 5 段階中 5 の評価SparklingEyes によるレビュー (18日前)Very nice add-on that improves the YouTube experience in many ways. The only feature I currently miss is volume control with the mouse wheel. Would be terrific if this could be added in the future. :)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Lilith D. Bracken によるレビュー (1ヶ月前)I really like this extension. It makes YouTube so much cleaner and easier to use. You can hide all the distracting stuff, change the layout, and add helpful tweaks that make watching and browsing feel smoother. It’s lightweight and doesn’t slow things down, which is great. The shortcuts and filters are super handy for managing videos and playlists too. Overall, it just makes YouTube feel more organized and personal. Once you start using it, it’s hard to imagine going back to the default version.
- 5 段階中 5 の評価elviomoura によるレビュー (1ヶ月前)