Revisiones de Silk - Privacy Pass Client
Silk - Privacy Pass Client por Cloudflare Research
Revisado por Usuario de Firefox 17530926
Se valoró con 1 de 5
por Usuario de Firefox 17530926, el hace 2 años710 revisiones
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por rhokstar, el hace 2 díasI've been using Privacy Pass to help reduce CAPTCHAs, but a recent update has introduced some concerning behavior that potential users should be aware of.
Pros:
- Can help reduce CAPTCHAs on some websites
- Open-source and maintained by Cloudflare
Cons:
- Recently started opening new tabs without user permission
- Asks for "attester" verification in an intrusive manner
- Interrupts browsing experience unexpectedly
The extension now opens a new tab without warning, asking users to verify an "attester." While this might be intended to improve transparency, the implementation is disruptive and feels like a violation of user control. This behavior seems to go against Firefox's add-on policies regarding unexpected actions and user experience. It's particularly concerning for an extension that's supposed to improve browsing, not interrupt it. I've reported this to Mozilla for review. In the meantime, users should be aware of this intrusive behavior before installing. If you value a smooth browsing experience without unexpected interruptions, you might want to consider alternatives or wait for this issue to be addressed. I hope the developers can find a less disruptive way to implement their verification process. Until then, I can't recommend this extension. - Se valoró con 1 de 5por James E. LaBarre, el hace 10 díasInstalled on Firefox, and the extension *****CANNOT***** be enabled. It's just as broken as Cloudflare itself. This extension CLAIMS to be able to stop the perpetual "Verify you are human" loop, but obviously their programming of the extension is just as shoddy as their filtering site. Verify I'm Human???? Cloudflare doesn't even have humans to answer how to FOX their BROKEN system.
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Octaviopk, el hace 2 meses
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por DogancanYr, el hace 2 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Aa, el hace 2 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 18364689, el hace 3 meses
- Se valoró con 3 de 5por Illuminator, el hace 3 meses
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 17422731, el hace 3 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Anthony Castanza, el hace 4 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por user 0928524114, el hace 5 mesesNot working even after latest update. New tab opens as shown on screenshot, sometimes fails to verify. Even if the new tab verifies, I have to verify once again on the site that requested it. So that's solving waiting two captchas each time to load and verify. The next time same story! What's the point then? Solving twice the amount of captchas and not even earning tickets for next captcha relief? No thanks. Useless addon made to waste users time.
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por George Pchelkin, el hace 6 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 14881252, el hace 6 mesesWhile the github has been updated since the last review claiming it might have been abandoned, it still doesn't work. The privacy pass page will pop up just as often as cloudflair normally would, and will in fact occasionally fail to properly identify you as human rather than a bot, making the extension entirely pointless
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por 90alx, el hace 6 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Bobby Wibowo, el hace 8 mesesHas stopped working since the past few weeks. According to the people at GitHub it's indeed broken and will require fixing. Unfortunately there have been no Git commits ever since, so it might be an abandonware.
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 17863214, el hace 8 mesesUseless now. hCaptcha dropped support and Cloudflare appears to have done so as well. Any site protected by Cloudflare just goes into an endless loop of "Are you human?". It's a sad state of the usability of the web that such a plugin is needed in the first place.
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 18106702, el hace 9 meses
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por ethcat, el hace 10 mesesThis is how human browse the web today. It's not Privacy Pass, it's Human Pass.
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por Geex, el hace 10 mesesDoesn't work at all, and also prevents sites from working correctly. Trashcan
- Se valoró con 5 de 5por Efiyo, el hace un año
- Se valoró con 3 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 14550105, el hace un año
- Se valoró con 4 de 5por ali, el hace un año
- Se valoró con 1 de 5por nibba111, el hace un añoOne of those cases where I'd happily give a zero-star rating, but there is no such thing. I guess one star can be given for the intention behind. Some issues:
1. Stores passes in localStorage. Due to this they get cleaned up by automatic cleaning, always if the browser is in permanent private mode (Tor Browser). If you don't use permanent private mode, instead automatically cleaning history on exit, you can put moz-extension://ea706443-32b7-4727-b136-408bf93e5004/ in cleaning exceptions, which is very unintuitive.
My passes getting deleted was a big surprise the first time...
It was even reported in the issue tracker (https://github.com/privacypass/challenge-bypass-extension/issues/205), yet dismissed by the dev. Somehow storing that in localStorage is not a bug.
How would you like uBlock rules cleared on every launch?
2. Can't coin passes in Tor Browser.
3. Buggy if you disabled WASM.
4. No functionality for import/export. But you can do it through debugging extension in a web inspector. I guess this is where localStorage comes useful but it still sucks. See https://pastebin.com/EgruhFQc for functions.
5. If you managed to import passes via own js in Tor Browser, or you switched to Tor in a normal one, it won't fully redeem them. In case of hCaptcha, it mistrusts you after you uselessly redeem a pass or two. In case of Cloudflare, most important sites that I use don't get highlighted by the extension. Websites like ChatGPT, some manga websites and forums, enter an endless loop with rotating thing on a page that uses deceptive language like "checking if your connection is secure", despite obviously not checking out the connection, but me. I haven't yet encountered a cloudflared website I use a lot which supports this.
5.1. No visual indicators that it mistrusts you despite eating a pass. No indicators if it works generally beyond using devtools. No status messages.
6. Only 5 hCaptcha passes for one completion.
7. Given that Privacy Pass as a standard will combat pass hoarding by associating passes with metadata (see the latter part of https://blog.cloudflare.com/privacy-pass-v3/), it's not very obvious why not just ditch tokens entirely and use registration with captchas (a la hCaptcha accessibility) to begin with. It's inevitable that you get rid of anonymity and stuff like that in order to not be frustrated with workarounds like this one. By registering with a captcha provider you might not need to redeem anything anymore, you can build trust in each internet-using biological platform on individual basis. - Se valoró con 5 de 5por Usuario de Firefox 15397935, el hace 2 añosLooking at the reviews, it seems YMMV with this add-on. That said, I have noticed a significant drop in captchas for myself.