Recently there has been a truly concerning uptick in trans-masculine people being marked as transphobic. I checked the blogs this applied to that I saw and none of them had said anything transphobic at all that I could see, the opposite. Most of them were actively discussing intersectionality in a nuanced way that did not show any hostility toward other trans people.

I can only assume there are some very petty and sad people targeting these people and to them I say, please stop this nonsense. This way the extension unfortunately has become unusable to figure out anything about someone's trans-friendliness

I've had this extension installed for many years, but in recent months, every page I've seen flagged anti-trans, with the exception of exactly one violently hateful one and its content, and things like, say, the Wikipedia page for JKR, has been a trans and/or intersex person who uplifts trans voices and practices extensive advocacy - the exact definition of what the extension guidelines define as pro-trans - who also discusses and uplifts intersex issues and voices. Meanwhile, genuine TERFs fly under the radar or are even marked pro-trans. It simply is not sufficiently effective for the purpose it was meant for anymore.

I just kept seeing blogs marked as anti-trans, even though the blogs in question were all about supporting nonbinary identities and didn't have any content that could be considered anti-trans. Even worse, from the shinigami eyes website: "While your overrides are immediately visible to you, changes are included in the publicly visible dataset only if they pass some trustworthiness criteria (including human validation)." What this tells me: people are marking nonbinary people/identities as "anti-trans", and whoever is looking at those reports is either agreeing with them or not paying attention. At least, that's what it looks like. Either way, there's too many cases of blogs being falsely marked as anti-trans, whatever the reason may be, which makes this extension useless.

i used to use this for several years... come to find out now the extensions used for targeted harrassment of trans men + marking intersex as anti trans for additional harrassment. seriously?

I have been a devout Shinigami Eyes user since the very beginning, but lately there has been a consistent uptick in people using it to target and harass people of the trans and queer community which I just can't abide by. Every tool that is used to help trans people is ultimately co-opted by bad faith interlopers and this is just another run of it. Until this gets addressed this extension is useless and a tool of the enemy. Anyone using this should remove it because right now they have made it completely useless putting fellow trans people against one another and putting them in the same category as people like Charlie Kirk, Jesse Waters, Marjorie Taylor Greene, etc all for speaking out against certain racist and misogynistic viewpoints within the trans community and the non-trans community widely.

This extension was useful several years ago, but now it's used to dismiss and attack transmasculine people, intersex people, and transfeminine people who speak up for their transmasc and intersex peers. It does not mark actual transmisogynists or transphobes as red, and is now less than useless.

This used to be a great extension, until it became weaponized by transphobes, especially against trans men, and used to harass intersex folks. The developers are part of the problem and actively propagate the issue.

This is not a review bomb score out of spite, but an earnest and heartbroken attempt to be honest here. I really did like Shinigami Eyes when it was primarily about marking institutions, or just users in general who are genuinely transphobic and wish harm to the entire trans community. It was an indicator to block these people so that they do not perform harmful actions against you, such as doxxing, which is uniquely harmful to trans people since it can out them to their families. It has helped me in the past to block some truly rancid individuals.

And now we're seeing a rise in false flagging against actual trans and intersex people as a means to harass them. In my opinion, while it is entirely possible for trans people to have internalized transphobia, this is extending far beyond the pale. It should not be necessary for me to personally act as a moderator and spend hours unflagging trans people who care deeply about supporting the community and who are themselves vulnerable and in need of support.

We're in an age of sliding backwards into conservatism and we need each other more than ever. This app is no longer serving to protect us. It's gotten to a point where asking for peace and solidarity is enough to be marked as red. If you don't see the problem with this, I implore you to look harder.

This plugin is no longer useful as it has been weaponized against non-feminine presenting trans people.

was good at first but seeing so many ppl marked as red on reddit made me lose my faith in humanity a little lol reddit sucks + what the other users are saying

Let me be very clear about one thing.
This plugin is no longer about trans safety. It’s run by white radqueers who weaponize identity to control the narrative. Their version of “protection” is exclusionary, and deeply racist.

These are the same people who tell trans men to detransition, harass intersex people. They've brought back slurs like “theyfab” and regurgitate 4chan-era “passoid” discourse from the sewers. They claim transmisogyny is theirs alone to suffer and gatekeep and they shut down anyone who won’t bow to their white-coded trauma pedestal.

It’s not a safety tool anymore.
It’s a litmus test, enforced by radfem-baeddel TERFs.

TL;DR:
Delete this plugin. It’s a bad-faith plugin, and is total garbage due to being poorly moderated by trans-exclusionary TERFS. This is no longer a tool for protecting trans people. This is a tool for fascist neo-liberals cosplaying as anarcholeftists in their mom's basement (and they kinda have the hots for her!)

Used to use this until I noticed it flagged one of my tranmasc friends as red, then I started seeing it flagging a lot of other trans men as red, along with a number of NB folk I follow. Found that to be pretty telling, and honestly pretty vile, ESPECIALLY in this day when all us queer folk are under threat. Solidarity forever.

I've used this add-on for years. I think it's great in theory. Unfortunately, I have seen a comical amount of Trans people marked red on places like bluesky, because they spoke up about transmedicalism and gatekeeping of nonbinary identities only to have some plugin users coordinate a mass marking that is opposite of their character. I can only assume as a user that the application is now compromised by bad actors. Until this is fixed, my review is: don't use this plugin, it is NOT reliable.

this used to be such a useful resource to find out if somebody was transphobic and then it all went down the gutter. Ive seen so many blogs run by transgender folk be marked red like what???

This app used to have ACTUAL moderation before but the sabotaging is ridiculous. Please do better.

Hello. I am transfeminine. I ask you read this review before continuing to read any others.

Many of the people rating this as "five stars" claim transmisogyny and "review bombing."

It is not review bombing. Most, if not all, of the one-star reviews are valid concerns and I have witness the things the one-star reviews are talking about with my own eyes. The people giving out one star reviews are not being transmisogynist. The fact that my own sisters in the trans community will claim such of people actually having grievances and struggles of their own appalls and disgusts me.

Most of the one-star reviews are discussing experiencing "transandrophobia," intersexism, and even racism at the hands of the developers of this extension. They speak of many people being completely, unfairly, and unjustly marked red, and I have seen this happening more and more often, and I find more and more people being marked green purely on the basis of being a trans woman.

This is actually a one-star review, but I wanted to put this here to challenge the people in the 5-star section having the disgusting gall to call our trans siblings "transmisogynist" for the mere fact that they are not trans women themselves.

And if one such reviewer is reading this...

Do better. I know you can. Fix your hearts.

Don't listen to the review bombers giving it one-stars: a group of spiteful people on tumblr are organizing to lower its score. Shinigami eyes is a great extension. The best thing about it is that it's open to the community- no individual person decides what's right or wrong. If you disagree with the way someone's been marked, you can correct it yourself. I like to treat it like a "heads up". If I see the red, I can look more closely at the source and decide for myself if I agree. If you're capable of critical thinking, you'll be fine. Its great to know other folks in the community are keeping at eye out.

i've used this extension for well over a decade and i really don't know what happened. it used to be useful, it really did, but now there's so much false flagging that it's basically meaningless. it's a shame how bad the moderation has gotten. i wish there was an extension like this that actually cared about people other than white perisex transfems, but if you don't happen to be part of that demographic or even if you are but like to advocate for other people's needs or issues, you and your mutuals will probably get marked red eventually. it's sad. transmascs and intersex people and especially people of color ily and you deserve better than this.

The extension was great, then recently a lot of trans-friendly accounts started coming up red. I don't know why and who is at fault and honestly don't have a reason nor energy to care. This is simply meant as a warning to not download, because it doesn't work the way it was supposed to.