This is an abusive extension that marked my trans activist friend as transphobic and some transphobe i know as GREEN

im pleased to say that this addon is beautiful and shows clearly the folks i can and cannot trust

love it hopefully people stop negative review bomming it

While a good idea in theory, this extension has become completely useless due to a variety of factors leading the information it provides to be unreliable. The main issues are as follows:

- There is no system to view the reason why someone is marked as either pro-trans or anti-trans; the extension instead expects you to trust its opaque data set without question. I'd find it hard to trust any source which makes bold claims regarding a person's bigotry (or lack thereof) without at least one specific example.

- The voting data is processed using an imprecise algorithm known as a "bloom filter" which has a tendency to erroneously categorize people in either the pro-trans or anti-trans category when there aren't actually any votes to support that.

- The anonymous voting is incredibly susceptible to false flags, particularly from exclusionist subgroups within the trans community. This leads to many transmasc, nonbinary and intersex people being marked as anti-trans in retaliation for pushing back against hatred directed towards them, while the people who spread that hate are marked as trans-friendly.

The result of this is a once useful tool becoming a vector for character assassination (whether intentional or not) of vulnerable trans people within our own community. I would not consider recommending this unless all of the above points are meaningfully addressed.

Hello. My name is Ash. I am transfeminine. I ask you read this review before reading any others.

I can personally attest that every one-star review talks about real issues that this add-on has.

I have personally witnessed:
Trans men being marked red for no reason (even after thorough investigation)
Intersex people that are explicitly pro-trans being marked red
BIPOC trans people of all stripes being marked red


This is not review bombing. I can confidently assure you that. Trans radfems, however, claim that it is such in order to silence others and push a hateful and supremacist agenda. Even a paltry investigation into this specific circle of the trans community will reveal exactly what I'm talking about, and I urge you to look into it yourself.

This is a one-star review in spirit. I am leaving this in the five-star section to warn others about the lies radfems are spreading about our trans siblings-in-arms.

Don't be fools. Go with compassion in your heart, always.

This extension is consistently extremely useful for rooting out people who have corrosive opinions. The low scores tend to be because the exact people that are marked as red have a tendency to lash out in the form of review bombing.

Notably: this extension is very good at marking transphobia generally, but with a focus on transmisogyny. There aren't a lot of systems to protect trans women these days, so this is an extremely encouraging tool.

Generally, the review bombing on this is disappointing. My assumption is that the goal here is to muddy the water on this extension or to get it taken down. It's consistently disappointing to see my community act like this.

At the end of the day, this is a tool to protect trans communities. If you're here for that, it's going to help with that. But it's only a tool, and it can only be as effective as a tool

while this works fine on other sites, on social medias it has become completely unusable. violent TERFs are marked green, while intersex activists or transmasculine people are marked red. i've seen people be marked green while saying they wish for the corrective r*pe of trans men or are advocating for the coercive correction of intersex people. absolute insanity. this extension does nothing but to stroke the egos of violent transphobes at this point.

Stop marking intersex people as transphobic jfc

Flags trans and intersex people as red. It clearly has bias against anyone who speaks out against transandrophobia and intersexism.

this extension is openly anti-ftm, anti-intersex, and anti-black. routinely flags actual trans people while transphobes are marked green. also does not tell you why someone is marked red or green.

Transphobic devs that exclude intersex/FtM people.
it's also just inaccurate as shit.
Doesn't tell you why somebody was marked red, either.

Great extension that works as intended. Don't mind the misinformation being spread by transphobes and transmisogynysts claiming it's false flagging people, it's not.

It used to be useful, but at this point so many trans folks (including trans feminine people and trans women!) are marked as red these days. The red markers tend to skew toward trans masculine or intersex people, and often crypto-terfs will mark themselves as green. All this does is cause confusion.

Ultimately this needs better moderation, and, preferably, a way to mark individual authors, contributors, and individuals instead of entire news sources or websites. It's kind of jarring to see an article about trans resources marked as red solely because it's on a website that was deemed wholly transphobic, rather than the individual authors of the articles.

Before this review, I'd like to say that I still use this extension, I just manually review people that I see marked as any color before making any judgements on a person.

Lately, this extension has taken a HUGE downfall on the quality of flags- most users I see marked as red are intersex activists or folks that talk about transandrophobia. Whilst I don't have much to talk about either of these matters, what bugs me is that people talking about these matters in positive OR negative light are being falsely flagged as red, despite being trans-friendly in the traditional sense- supporting trans people across the entire spectrum of gender.

I think until a user is being actively transphobic, I.E mis/disgendering people, using transphobic slurs as derogatory slurs, or sharing misinformation about trans people and their experiences, they shouldn't be marked as red. Disagree all you want on what terms are real and fake, but don't let it cloud your sense of judgement- they're still an ally to transgenderism, however that may be.

inaccurate for most red eyes. green is usually accurate but red is incredibly inconsistent. transgender pro trans activists are red, intersex-activists are red, people that are active in the trans activism community that are explicitly pro trans are red. can be weaponized really easily, and needs better moderation

You can personally tag and change the red/green markers, but the ones shown to the public are manually reviewed by people with a bias towards transmedicalism. On non-socialmedia sites, it is useful. Everywhere else, it is not.

Too many people are getting false-flagged--it's now more an extension for transphobes to smear trans people with than actually warning you about transphobes.

Don't install Shinigami Eyes. Its accuracy is EXTREMELY low, and it oftentimes mistakes actual transgender people for transphobes and vice versa. This is not a reliable application in its implementation, and it seems to frequently mismark transgender individuals who do not identify with a binary gender in a traditional way (ex. people who don't fit into categories such as stereotypical boys who like blue and girls who like pink). I do not know if that is by design, but it would not surprise me if it was so.

I've noticed over the past few months that several very innocuous intersex and nonbinary accounts on Tumblr have been marked as transphobic. I was not able to find anything to back this up in my own searching. I did, however, see a sharp increase in people reporting false tags over the same period of time I've noticed them.

I will be removing this extension until the developers are able to correct this wash of inaccurate, false flagging.

In my experience most of the negative reviews come as a result of Shinigami Eyes being very good about catching transphobia directed at trans women. When you prioritize the most vulnerable those who previously saw themselves in that position often grow frustrated. This is still a great way to understand who you're interacting with online. Don't be a trans-misogynist if you want to remain green - pretty simple <3

I used to use it because it was good at pointing out transphobes. Now, it's useless. All I see is trans people marked as red, and actual transphobes unmarked or marked green. The team in charge of it is unreliable.