บทวิจารณ์สำหรับ 'Improve YouTube!' 🎧 (For YouTube & Video)
'Improve YouTube!' 🎧 (For YouTube & Video) โดย code-for-charity, ImprovedTube
บทวิจารณ์โดย Savannah
ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 1 จาก 5
โดย Savannah, 2 ปีที่แล้วMore edit: Cannot view comments when this app is enabled, regardless of whether I select "shown", "collapsed", or "hidden". This makes this add-on's single most useful feature unusable, and I'm on the verge of uninstalling.
Edit: I've tried previous versions and the issue is still there. Edit: 1) The "won't play" issue turned out to be caused by turning off "Autoplay" under "Player". I assume and hope this isn't intended behaviour. 2) The "top and bottom are cut off" issue turned out to be caused by turning off "limit page width". To me it seems backwards that there's an option that needs to be switched ON to maintain normal behaviour, and causes abnormal (and undesirable) behaviour when you switch it OFF. I feel like it should be the other way around. 3) No, I don't have a rare computer or system. Edit: I thought the Autoplay setting was causing the pausing issue, as it seemed to go away whenever I turned it off and come back when I turned it on. This is no longer the case. So I guess that's not the cause after all.
This COULD be really great, and would replace at least two other addons for me. It's also the only addon I've found that can hide comments without getting rid of the comment field, a feature I've wanted for a long time. But I can't play YouTube videos when I have this enabled! It will only play a frame or maybe a few frames at a time before pausing again by itself. And even when it does play, the top and bottom of the video are cut off! I've experimented with all the settings and nothing helps. Disabling my other YouTube-related addons didn't help either.
Edit: I've tried previous versions and the issue is still there. Edit: 1) The "won't play" issue turned out to be caused by turning off "Autoplay" under "Player". I assume and hope this isn't intended behaviour. 2) The "top and bottom are cut off" issue turned out to be caused by turning off "limit page width". To me it seems backwards that there's an option that needs to be switched ON to maintain normal behaviour, and causes abnormal (and undesirable) behaviour when you switch it OFF. I feel like it should be the other way around. 3) No, I don't have a rare computer or system. Edit: I thought the Autoplay setting was causing the pausing issue, as it seemed to go away whenever I turned it off and come back when I turned it on. This is no longer the case. So I guess that's not the cause after all.
This COULD be really great, and would replace at least two other addons for me. It's also the only addon I've found that can hide comments without getting rid of the comment field, a feature I've wanted for a long time. But I can't play YouTube videos when I have this enabled! It will only play a frame or maybe a few frames at a time before pausing again by itself. And even when it does play, the top and bottom of the video are cut off! I've experimented with all the settings and nothing helps. Disabling my other YouTube-related addons didn't help either.
การตอบกลับของนักพัฒนา
โพสต์เมื่อ 2 ปีที่แล้วEDIT2: ah! hey, probably the autoplay setting! (i couldn't reproduce either in the latest Firefox. But it was reported 3 times by now)
https://github.com/code-for-charity/YouTube-Extension/issues/1213 ( The other setting is new and could also be called "Unlimited page width" to be more intuitive. (even though technically it is something that Youtube visually does by default already and we just switch it off. We can always improve and make the most important features bigger and label some others as rare/specific. But this is an avid task and not trivial and should not be required to avoid low ratings ( https://github.com/code4charity/YouTube-Extension/discussions/748 )
- this project is actually is the only existing solution for many things and the most convenient one too in comparision. Most settings allow to see the effect instantly on the current page, unlike all alternatives, that require to make settings in different tabs. (- yet 'youtube enhancer' & 'magic actions for youtube' do have a million more users still) - and bad ratings might make the gap bigger if anything.
(To be more precise, the width limit feature is meant to allow the site/video to expand to the sides. This means, if you have a superwide screen or also hide related videos, then the video height wont fit fully, unless you also hide the youtube header, or zoom or use auto-fullscreen. We are not a one-fit-all solution by definition for a billion users like YouTube itself. We volunteer to serve specific wishes. Most users are willing to experiment for some minutes for once. In a 100 features a few will in fact naturally not help you. All of which we can try to label perfectly in the next update, but never avoid completely, by nature of even having more than a few features. You can still refer to your list of 'activiated Features' (and currently this feature only appears once you disabled the button.) (You can also reset our settings to go back to YouTube defaults.) Anything could be labeled or come with an alert, but thats also complification in the eyes of other users. (You don't need to click a button unless it makes sense to you.)
----------
EDIT: Thanks, tough luck* - Almost there though! (*this confirms it is a rare bug. However we will be happy to fix it for you in time!) - Did you notice the last 4 Versions are all within a few days?😊 - If you go back a step further (3.223 or 3.899), then it works most-likely and you will have discover easily, at what version the bug starts🤩. (Finally, you probably have a rare computer or system? (and can see whats happening in the browser console?) bugs@improvedtube.com. BTW you can quickly try an extension in a private tab, with no other extension running just to make sure) -----------------
hi, thanks. Please understand some bugs are rare and bad luck. The bigger a project is, the less likely you run into any, but it can't be excluded completely. To find it fastest you might need to report more details ( https://github.com/code4charity/YouTube-Extension/issues ). Also likely it just started yeserday and was not there in the prevous versions, which you can still get. Many Features: Yes, browser extensions are unfortunately supposed/presented to be small/single-purpose. Still we are providing a 100 of the most wished and requested features without 100 times more success than easy extensions. This is also much more teditious than making our own site which would be fun/need no maintenance. We are volunteers working hard. Youtube has a billion times more money than us. So you might not want to give 1 star, to support the cause getting anywhere near as much visiblity, as it deserves (and consequently even faster fixes) Many smiles!
https://github.com/code-for-charity/YouTube-Extension/issues/1213 ( The other setting is new and could also be called "Unlimited page width" to be more intuitive. (even though technically it is something that Youtube visually does by default already and we just switch it off. We can always improve and make the most important features bigger and label some others as rare/specific. But this is an avid task and not trivial and should not be required to avoid low ratings ( https://github.com/code4charity/YouTube-Extension/discussions/748 )
- this project is actually is the only existing solution for many things and the most convenient one too in comparision. Most settings allow to see the effect instantly on the current page, unlike all alternatives, that require to make settings in different tabs. (- yet 'youtube enhancer' & 'magic actions for youtube' do have a million more users still) - and bad ratings might make the gap bigger if anything.
(To be more precise, the width limit feature is meant to allow the site/video to expand to the sides. This means, if you have a superwide screen or also hide related videos, then the video height wont fit fully, unless you also hide the youtube header, or zoom or use auto-fullscreen. We are not a one-fit-all solution by definition for a billion users like YouTube itself. We volunteer to serve specific wishes. Most users are willing to experiment for some minutes for once. In a 100 features a few will in fact naturally not help you. All of which we can try to label perfectly in the next update, but never avoid completely, by nature of even having more than a few features. You can still refer to your list of 'activiated Features' (and currently this feature only appears once you disabled the button.) (You can also reset our settings to go back to YouTube defaults.) Anything could be labeled or come with an alert, but thats also complification in the eyes of other users. (You don't need to click a button unless it makes sense to you.)
----------
EDIT: Thanks, tough luck* - Almost there though! (*this confirms it is a rare bug. However we will be happy to fix it for you in time!) - Did you notice the last 4 Versions are all within a few days?😊 - If you go back a step further (3.223 or 3.899), then it works most-likely and you will have discover easily, at what version the bug starts🤩. (Finally, you probably have a rare computer or system? (and can see whats happening in the browser console?) bugs@improvedtube.com. BTW you can quickly try an extension in a private tab, with no other extension running just to make sure) -----------------
hi, thanks. Please understand some bugs are rare and bad luck. The bigger a project is, the less likely you run into any, but it can't be excluded completely. To find it fastest you might need to report more details ( https://github.com/code4charity/YouTube-Extension/issues ). Also likely it just started yeserday and was not there in the prevous versions, which you can still get. Many Features: Yes, browser extensions are unfortunately supposed/presented to be small/single-purpose. Still we are providing a 100 of the most wished and requested features without 100 times more success than easy extensions. This is also much more teditious than making our own site which would be fun/need no maintenance. We are volunteers working hard. Youtube has a billion times more money than us. So you might not want to give 1 star, to support the cause getting anywhere near as much visiblity, as it deserves (and consequently even faster fixes) Many smiles!
479 บทวิจารณ์
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Nioner, 21 ชั่วโมงที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Raiden, 4 วันที่แล้วI would use this addon if the function that removes clutter (related videos, "recommended for you" stuff, etc etc) is more developed and working properly. Regularly checked if it actually works. Because I know google screws around and tweaks youtube so that many addons related to search results become dysfunctional. When I search and have the "remove related search results" turned on, then I want that to really work, and not face those unwanted videos to sneak up entirely all over the page. And by regularly checked and improved I mean for example one could improve that function by also allowing a ban of all those auto-generated playlists (so called youtube mix), and also the horizontal card lists (videos appear in a horizontal rows on a bar and scroll from left to right or right to left. This appears right in the middle of search results also (so I'm not talking about youtuber homepages).
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย ผู้ใช้ Firefox 18158169, 4 วันที่แล้วexactly what I needed to filter out watched videos and remove those crappy "featured" advertisement. With ublock and this extension I feel complete. Ty software dev for making this great extension
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย uzaylul, 4 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย ผู้ใช้ Firefox 18320622, 7 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย QΔQ, 10 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย ผู้ใช้ Firefox 18328184, 14 วันที่แล้วThe option to play videos from the beginning no longer works. It also happens that this extension makes the platform slower, with thumbnails that take longer to load for example.
-----------------
EDIT : Thank you for your reply !
I downloaded the "4.642" version and the option is working fine now.
And the problem with the thumbnails was because I had activated the option to have the thumbnails in HD (my bad).
Thank you for your work
-----------------
EDIT 2 : The option from the previous versions works, but not all the time. The Github topic should not have been closed!การตอบกลับของนักพัฒนา
โพสต์เมื่อ 13 วันที่แล้วhi! :) 1. https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues/1904
2. Did you select HD thumbnails? (maybe we will make this option legacy only, or offer it on 4k or 8k screens only..) - ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย ToastyMarv, 14 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Josphat, 16 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 1 จาก 5โดย Bearsjunior, 16 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Areera, 17 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Sack, 18 วันที่แล้วThis is a must have for someone that watches way too much YouTube. One thing I can suggest is to be able hide theater mode button. This is mostly a me problem I'm sure but I don't like theater mode and I find myself hitting it by accident sometimes. Also, I gotta say the like and dislike thing is confusing and now sure what it does. Deleted my bring back dislikes extension because I figured that is what it meant. Even if they aren't perfectly accurate, I think it would be nice for the users of at least this app to show dislikes
edit: Bumped from 4 to 5 since I now know you can block theater mode and I didn't not know the return YT dislikes was made difficult to implement for the reason stated. Great app that is a game changer and keep it up the work. You make the website I have the most hours on a lot better place.การตอบกลับของนักพัฒนา
โพสต์เมื่อ 17 วันที่แล้วhi! thanks! but with 4 stars you decrease our visibility which is unfair / low already.
Something 'missing' here is rarely a reason for deductions as there are unlimited questions and ideas and we already do too much and have to tidy first. You can hide the theater view button at appearance: player: player controls buttons: view mode. And you can join us on GitHub to improve this linguistically. It is a good idea to integrate data like sponsorblock or rytd, who might be gatekeeping one way or another: https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike#api-documentation. (If you spend an hour as a user that is a lot, still chances are people who spent 1000s of hours asked the same questions already. Thats why our Github appears on the front screen recently. - ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย ผู้ใช้ Firefox 12981342, 19 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Patnther2, 19 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 1 จาก 5โดย Drafer, 20 วันที่แล้วNe radi ništa kako treba, ako imam otvorenih nekoliko tabova na youtube on ih otvara sve pa je bolje ne imati ništa nego ovo sranje
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 4 จาก 5โดย ผู้ใช้ Firefox 14935735, 21 วันที่แล้ว... after trying several of the more highly rated extensions, this did come off as the best of the group... imagine why it's received the "recommended" rating
การตอบกลับของนักพัฒนา
โพสต์เมื่อ 18 วันที่แล้วhi, thanks, a big reason for Mozilla might/should be, because it is open-source? And we do this since 2012 for 400000 users in chrome, etc. Please consider, contrary to the comment, with 4 stars you are actually shrinking (down-voting) this project. (If you found any bugs: https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/issues?q=label%3Abug+sort%3Acomments-desc+is%3Aopen ) - ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Yuri M., 21 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Prankhimjohn, 22 วันที่แล้วWork perfectly as intended. I wish when I applyed black theme the like buttion stayed white but other then that 5/5 would use again! I LOVE the Auto- skip ads mode and auto- theader mode.
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย Coost, 22 วันที่แล้วОднозначно 5 звёзд, то что нужно.
Выставил нужное качество, и забыл про этот долбаный режим "авто".
Других плюшек тоже много. - ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 5 จาก 5โดย tob1KEA, 25 วันที่แล้ว
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 3 จาก 5โดย Banana, 25 วันที่แล้วThe settings under "general" and "channel" don't work at all
- ได้รับการจัดอันดับ 1 จาก 5โดย Dashing Rapscallion, 25 วันที่แล้ว