Doesn't consistently identify password fields, and will mistake things like search fields for password fields, but all in all is a sleek, feature packed alternative to things like Bitwarden.

Very good pw manager. Still some things to improve but it seems like theyr working on it

This extension is practically unusable on multiple website since the last update, JS is sometime not rendered at all and some functionalities are not properly working because of the extension
Really disappointed with proton pass and moving back to 1password at least I'll have my money worth

[EDIT] Bug fixed. User Happy :)

Le dernier module 1.15 a été retiré par Proton (Signalé et échange par mail avec eux) car bugué, le 1.14.1 est revenu en ligne en attendant un correctif

Truly a quality pass manager, even at the free level.

Pros- Unlimited login creations, built in 2fa TOTP, secured notes, and if you desire cards, id, etc.

Cons- limited to 1 or 2 vaults for creation without upgrade. Gets cluttered.

Similarly to a competitor atleast in this area of privacy, a built in device / cloud TOTP & Use for security keys like a if it was physical one. Proton should definitely add this.

Changing passwords is a usual safe protocol, as well as the backup codes and files. The security depth, can sometimes make this a headache.

The addon works well, considering that it hasn't been out that long.

Great add-on, but I'm missing functionality such as custom fields and separate username and email fields.

Simplicity, efficient, strong secured, robust, Open Source, Well-located.

After Lastpass, 1password, Bitwarden, Chrome, Firefox, Keepass... (yes...) this password manager begin to be really competitive and efficient compared to the bests. And it's my prefered for it's ethical and because independance have a price. But they done it free because of a strong economic plan based on a full desktop tools (mail calendar enterprise plan etc...)

This manager can :
Detect, copy, fill, autofill, autogenerate aliases emails (SimpleLogin) and password, detect favicons, really advanced in security.

The autofill for OTP is a popup on extension and secured clipboard not interactive on mobile.

In-Extension password editor is strong and robust on Firefox.

I really appreciate :
- the popup's extension keep in memory forms states when you are editing an entry.
- No desktop app needed
- Robust Import from a lot of sources csv and other Password manager
- Really efficient and well thinked settings

The few bugs or missing are really low and not obstructive for a new comer :
Missing : plateforme (Google,Apple,Microsoft...) authentication manager.
Raretime the autogenerated password is not copying correctly or the account is not automatically created. (I'm on OSX).

Missing options to optimise for me :
- Adding more line types like Addresses of License key or a line for remplacing password by hardware keys or linked to Google Apple Microsoft... accounts
- i hope SimpleLogin within account entry and not in another note, but it's backing up old aliases.
- Better detect forms data and save them (a few could not be registered automatically)
- Generated password could be pinned in a On-Top Extension Popup Windows before continuing, canceling or saving...
- Advanced fine-tuned option for generator like passphrase, lengh etc.. or sentence is missing. I well know that Proton Team would generate a password complying all websites.

But you become exigent when quality coding is here.

It's not perfect, but thanks to recent updates, it has improved significantly! The overall experience has become quite enjoyable.

However, there is room for improvement in the user experience (UX). For instance, when trying to click on the 'create login' link within an alias's details, there's a risk of accidentally clicking on the alias, copying it and overwriting the password stored in the clipboard.

This situation arises because the extension occasionally fails to recognize that I've completed the registration process. As a result, I end up having to manually create a login with a generated alias. Unfortunately, the 'create login' link is very small and it's easy to missclick.

At first, this was just a very smooth password manager that was way more responsive than lastpass but it had issues. It was missing sharing, an easier way to manage your passwords, and emergency access.
Now it has 2 of those things. The sharing works very smoothly and it's great. The only thing it needs now is the emergency access. After that, this app will fully replace other password managers.
Even now you can move over and be satisfied with it.

I am looking for passkeys support but is missing

Like the Proton brand focused on customer privacy so have high hopes for this. A great start but some key functions not there...for example, many sites have more than two inputs to log in. Proton Pass only will recognize 2 so a lot of "cutting and pasting". Also some password managers will enable configuration of specific inputs to specific fields (in case the password manager can't figure out which field matches with what data is in the manager).
But the more one uses protonpass, the better it seems to work. Hopefully they will fix the limitations with quick updates.