Thanks for the review. Unfortunately I wasn't able to reproduce the issue you described when I went to YouTube.

Sort of reminds me of how pressing Alt (and bringing up the application's menu) can sometimes block hotkeys though (fixable by clicking anywhere on the page and trying again). If you've freshly installed or enabled the add-on this (and most) add-ons won't run until the page is refreshed as well.

If those don't help, then I'll probably need more information to try and help you with your issue, like what website and what other add-ons or settings that might be different than default Firefox on Windows. You can email me with the Support email link and I'll be happy to help!

Thanks for the review and for letting me know about the Netflix support.

The next release will feature proper Netflix support although it may be some time before the next release.

Hmm, very mysterious. I just tested the extension with the latest Firefox (121.0.1) on Win10, Win11, Linux Mint, and MacOS with a YouTube video and everything seemed to work.

While testing with a YouTube video (in a normal window, not private) you could try:
- Making sure the video is playing before using the hotkeys.
- Clicking on an open spot of the website before trying a hotkey.
- Resetting the hotkeys to Default or Alternative and try those hotkeys.
- Setting a custom hotkey and then trying it.
- Uninstalling the extension and reinstalling it. This will fully reset all settings.
- Disabling all other extensions in case one of them is interfering with this one.

If those don't help, I'll probably need more information to try and reproduce the problem like: video URL, OS, Firefox version, any custom settings, hotkey combinations, any other differences, etc. Feel free to email me in that case and I can help you get it working.

Thanks for the review!

Sadly, yes, currently not possible with Firefox's built-in pop out player to my knowledge.

I may try my hand at making a separate extension that allows this on Chrome and mostly allows this for Firefox (with a window title-bar showing). Unfortunately it won't be perfect on YouTube because of all the extra queuing, mini players, custom playlists and such can't really be supported properly with the method I'm envisioning.

I'd love to learn more about this use case, like what websites you generally use for pop out and I assume on Windows? Feel free to email me if you feel like it :).

Thanks for the review!

Yup, solo dev over here. Certainly not an accident that it works as well as it does: attention to detail, a *lot* of testing and good feedback from users :).

As for tracking and general malicious add-ons, you can never be too cautious. Security and privacy are very important to me so I rarely run add-ons I haven't made myself.

That being said, I'll do everything in my power to safeguard the privacy and security of the users of my add-ons. The add-ons I've created were designed to be secure, minimal, concise, easily audited, never load external code, and free of obfuscation (packing).

You can probably get Mozilla to look over my code more thoroughly (I'm hoping especially for updates) if you recommend my add-on to be featured like it is in Chrome's Webstore.
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/recommended-extensions-program

(I'll probably do this myself as soon as I make a real internationalized website for this since I'm a bit of a perfectionist.)

Stay vigilant! :)

Thanks for the review and I'm glad you're finding the extension useful. It's valuable for me to hear how people are using the extension.

Also, great suggestion! I'll link up the settings page to that Options menu in Manage Extensions in the next version.

I'm glad you're finding this extension useful. And yes, the core functionality will stay the same as it's how I like it too :). Thanks for the review!