JamesGecko

À propos de moi

Information développeur
Nom JamesGecko
Utilisateur depuis jan. 9, 2011
Nombre de modules développés 0 modules
Moyenne des notes des modules du développeur Pas encore évalué

Mes critiques

Firefox Multi-Account Containers

Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

Great idea with serious usability issues. It's way too easy to accidentally open a new tab in the global container space. The addon should bind to Ctrl+T or provide it's own keyboard shortcut to open a new tab in the current container. Ctrl+. is too indirect. It's also annoying to have a delayed confirmation that a site should always open in a specific container after explicitly checking the "Always open in (container)" box. Finally, the "flicker" when opening a new tab that is set to always open in a certain container is bad. I think it's opening a normal tab, then closing it and opening a container tab? It's distracting and looks broken.

Groupes d'Onglets

Lots of changes; questionable UX decisions Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

Version 1 of tab groups was exactly the functionality that was removed from Firefox, no more and no less. It was good. Version 2 is not necessarily a great upgrade.

After upgrading, the behavior of tab groups abruptly changed. The options screen had terminology I was unfamiliar with and it wasn't immediately obvious how to return to old behavior (I eventually found the "free arrange" button). I don't really trust the developer not to yank the rug out from under me again.

Animation when switching to (free arrange) group view has been removed. While this makes it feel slightly snappier, it makes the plugin harder to use. Animation was an important visual cue showing where the tab you were just looking at had been minimized.

Other questionable new UI decisions include burying the tab group thumbnail view (the reason I'm using the plugin) in a menu by default, adding inconsistent terminology (single view, grid layout, grid display, free arrange), and moving buttons around randomly depending on which layout/view/display/arrangement (just pick a term already!) you're using. Also, free arrange looks kinda ugly now.

V2 is also more spammy. A tab opened with release notes on upgrade. The options have a bouncing icon in the bottom left corner. Clicking on it shows a banner ad. One of the first times I opened group view, a popup appeared asking me to give the developer money. If it gets much worse, I'm just going to fork the plugin and run version 1 forever.

The new "single view" mode isn't even bad. I'm just frustrated that the classic "free arrange" mode I installed the plugin for is suddenly worse.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (2.0.1). 

Custom Tab Width

Does what it says, works fine Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Never had it break; using it in Firefox 46 with no issues.

Pocket

Awesome, except... Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

Everything about the extension is great except for the Tab Groups drop target. I've lost so many tab groups to it accidentally that I've uninstalled the extension.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (3.0.0.1-signed).