Critiques pour Return YouTube Dislike
Return YouTube Dislike par Dmitry Selivanov
Avis de Bubbl
Noté 5 sur 5
par Bubbl, il y a un moisAnd now it requires PII. Shame.
Edit: bit of a knee-jerk reaction from my part, I should have researched about it more before instantly giving it a one star. Thank you for the response, reverted the score 5 stars as it still does what it says it does.
Edit: bit of a knee-jerk reaction from my part, I should have researched about it more before instantly giving it a one star. Thank you for the response, reverted the score 5 stars as it still does what it says it does.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a un moisThanks for sharing your concerns.
RYD hasn’t changed how it handles your data. What changed is how Mozilla labels these permissions - not what the extension does with your data.
Ajay, the author of SponsorBlock and DeArrow, describes the same problem here:
https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/the-new-data-transmission-permissions-seem-to-be-misleading-to-users/149410
The extension is actually recommended by Mozilla, so they do not consider it harmful or dangerous.
RYD’s site permissions cover only YouTube and its own API at returnyoutubedislikeapi.com. It doesn’t read other websites, and these site permissions can’t be used to access them. It only uses the data it needs to show dislikes and count votes.
Here’s what each label means:
Personally identifying information - RYD’s randomly generated user ID, used to count votes. It isn’t derived from or linked to your Google or YouTube account.
Browsing activity - when you open a YouTube video, the extension sends its video ID to fetch the dislike count.
Website content - things like the visible like count, which helps estimate dislikes.
Website activity - your Like or Dislike click, which counts as your vote.
The new labels sound scary, but they don’t give the extension access to any more websites. It isn’t watching what you do across the internet - with these site permissions, it simply can’t.
RYD is open source, so you can see exactly how it works: https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike
RYD hasn’t changed how it handles your data. What changed is how Mozilla labels these permissions - not what the extension does with your data.
Ajay, the author of SponsorBlock and DeArrow, describes the same problem here:
https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/the-new-data-transmission-permissions-seem-to-be-misleading-to-users/149410
The extension is actually recommended by Mozilla, so they do not consider it harmful or dangerous.
RYD’s site permissions cover only YouTube and its own API at returnyoutubedislikeapi.com. It doesn’t read other websites, and these site permissions can’t be used to access them. It only uses the data it needs to show dislikes and count votes.
Here’s what each label means:
Personally identifying information - RYD’s randomly generated user ID, used to count votes. It isn’t derived from or linked to your Google or YouTube account.
Browsing activity - when you open a YouTube video, the extension sends its video ID to fetch the dislike count.
Website content - things like the visible like count, which helps estimate dislikes.
Website activity - your Like or Dislike click, which counts as your vote.
The new labels sound scary, but they don’t give the extension access to any more websites. It isn’t watching what you do across the internet - with these site permissions, it simply can’t.
RYD is open source, so you can see exactly how it works: https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike
5 352 notes
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 18899970 de Firefox, il y a 12 heuresRecent (hidden) update now collects your data. Even if the creator of this extension, who tries to silence you by getting as many one star reviews removed as possible, denies it - you can easily verify this for yourself. Would not recommend.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 7 heuresI'm not removing any, well, I cannot remove them after all. I reported one pro-Russian Nazi for racial solos. That was one episode in entire. The history of this addon. And considering you being butthurt, are you that pro-russian nazi? Who got his ass handed twice in a row by the moderation team of Mozilla? LOL - Noté 1 sur 5par Review, il y a un jour1 star for two reasons: 1) Update requires giving personal information to the extension and their "15 TB database" and 2) creator is a communist begging for money for an extension that have 7 pages of similar extensions
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a un jourThose 7 pages of similar extensions all use my servers.
The DB isn't with your data - it's with likes and dislikes - to show them to you.
Genius. - Noté 3 sur 5par sealovedmoon, il y a un jourPreviously wrote a review complaining about the description not being updated, now it has been updated to mention the permission changes, which is great. Still not fond of the whole analytics subscription stuff being a thing you are not made aware of until *after* you install the addon, though. (I can't even find this mentioned at all on the repo or website... really?)
It's entirely understandable there needs to be some form of monetary support, I have absolutely nothing against this. But if it ever happens that you start your browser and an addon opens a new tab telling you to pay for something you never installed that addon for, it is adware and it prompts removing the addon responsible for it.
The developer response claims "The message about new features is shown only once during the lifetime of the extension, and it’s timed to appear after a browser restart - hopefully the least disruptive moment", which I mean, *should* be true. The addon does open a new tab to show you those 'hidden' features right after installing the extension. However, one day it opened a new tab out of nowhere, after I've had the addon installed for a very long while. Which just makes it seem like it will randomly do this every once in a while.
I personally will give the addon another chance, with the hopes that it will never randomly open that new tab, beyond the mostly-acceptable one it opens after install.Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a un jourThanks for report - I wouldn't trade good will of users for a popup intentionally (plus I don't expect annoying users would be beneficial monetarily), I will investigate the bug. In the end it is in my best interest to keep the users happy.
Do you, by chance, remember - was it the same tab you see on extension install?
And when did it happen? I.e. just recently - or some time ago?
And do you have a regular firefox? Or may be nightly or some modification - like waterfox, librefox, etc?
Thanks a lot for your time. And for even better support - you can come to github or discord (if you have accounts - if not - here is fine too). - Noté 2 sur 5par azyybb, il y a 2 joursAsking for money but vibeslopping their landing and extension pages and addon updates.. bullshit, a raw html file would do better than this vibeslop.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 2 joursLanding is older than AI. AI just trained on my landing - check github history - these LLMs didn't exist when it was written. I am (well, not I, but an unpaid volunteer who created that page) - is just a father of all AI slop, because it copied our style.
And yeah, first version of landing - by me - not by volunteers - was just a raw html. Check it out in way back machine. - Noté 1 sur 5par shady, il y a 3 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 13297502 de Firefox, il y a 7 joursAs with the earlier version, this version ALSO does NOT show the YouTube Dislikes....you know...the thing the entire addon is supposed to do....uninstall and will try again when next version is released (what's so hard to show the freakin dislikes now....), Using Latest Firefox update if that has any significance to the problem.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 7 joursAre you, by any chance, in a country with high censorship? (Like russia or countries depending on russia for providing internent - mostly central asia)?
Those get issues due to blocks of cloudflare sometimes.
Considering ~20 million active users across platforms - this one is likely more of your personal setup issue. - Noté 1 sur 5par bojlerguy, il y a 9 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par ResodentOfAgartha, il y a 11 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Toby, il y a 12 joursReading so many of the recent reviews gave me a headache. No this isn't trying to suddenly 'steal your data'. Mozilla has simply changed how they define certain permissions. Please read a little before submitting your angry review. This extension is basically essential to enjoy YouTube, thank you to the dev and I hope you don't lose your sanity replying to all these insane reviews. I know I would give up within days lol.
- Noté 1 sur 5par Kooxpi, il y a 12 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par wynter, il y a 13 joursi did not ask for all of these new features. i did not ask for a "Return YouTube Dislike chatroom" below every YouTube video. i downloaded this extension *only* to show me dislikes, *nothing* else.
Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 12 joursThe problem is - someone has to pay for you to see those dislikes. I wish hosting a 15TB database for 20 million users was free - unfortunately communism hasn't won yet - and we have to live in a world governed by money. - Noté 4 sur 5par baashdi, il y a 14 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 20302634 de Firefox, il y a 14 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 15331730 de Firefox, il y a 15 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par dpanter, il y a 16 jours
- Noté 1 sur 5par ViperouS, il y a 16 jours
- Noté 5 sur 5par Vy Vance, il y a 16 joursI'm not concerned at all about the new permissions -- it's the exact same thing as before, but looks "worse" (though still relatively harmless) due to re-labeling on behalf of Mozilla.
I get it, of course it's violently irritating to see something like that pop up regardless of circumstances. But my friends, there's literally zero difference between this new permission notification and the previous permissions with regard to privacy. It seems that Mozilla is just trying to be clearer about permissions (which is actually a good thing). It can make extensions/permissions look more intimidating than they actually are sometimes because the categories are so broad. Nothing permission-wise has actually changed.
This isn't even a Return YouTube Dislike changing their permissions thing, it's just a "Mozilla decided to re-label some stuff" thing. All gucci.
...Heh, I'd be remiss if I didn't mention that if I were to ever pay a monthly subscription for an extension, though, I would be figuratively (and possibly literally) smoking the crack. I would be happy to pay a one-time purchase/donation like DeArrow, though (it doesn't have to just be $1, lol).
So yes, I admit that Netflix and it's consequences have been a disaster for the "people who can do basic multiplication and understand $15 a month = $150 a year" race. I would never attempt to deny that. I'm happy to see you earning something back for all your hard work on creating/upkeeping this thing, though.
People rarely want to give developers enough credit (let alone anything of actual monetary value) for the extensions that they figure just magically exist and upkeep themselves for free. As long as it's all for new, extra stuff (and original functions don't get locked behind a paywall as "features"), I'm all for it.
God bless, hope the negative reviews ease off once people actually start to understand what is happening (and that you've done literally nothing wrong.) xoxox - Noté 5 sur 5par aggrave, il y a 16 joursLike many others, the new permissions thing concerned me, but unlike many others I actually looked into it and - like other reviews say - it's just a change on how Mozilla defines these permissions. Let this hopefully be a lesson to at least one person to research something before making conclusions.
- Noté 1 sur 5par Utilisateur ou utilisatrice 14484365 de Firefox, il y a 16 joursMassive YT slowdowns.
- Noté 5 sur 5par pandazorus, il y a 17 joursHello Dmiry. Thanks for this extension. I've been using it for years without issues.
Like many others, the recent permissions change felt fishy and prompted me to take a look at reviews.
It appears that the change is safe and that it's Firefox's new permission model that is somewhat misleading.
I suggest that you display an explanatory statement before the extension requests the new permission. You already kind of did, but it does not explain *why* such "intrusive" permissions are now required. Thanks.Réponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 17 joursHi, yep, working on making wording a bit clearer - Noté 3 sur 5par prospectus, il y a 17 jours"Optional data collection, according to the developer:
Authentication information
Browsing activity
Personally identifying information
Website activity
Website content"
Apparently not "optional" anymore, as I can't use the extension without showing my browsing activity, etc. I have uninstalled this extension until this privacy concern is corrected
EDIT: If is the case that it's a FF enforced label, then the developer should update the description of their extension, because it currently leads the users into believing these are optional permissions, when they are notRéponse du développeur
mis en ligne : il y a 17 joursThat is not my choice though - it's FF decision to label extension reading YouTube video url as "tracking website activity" - and without these permissions - extension simply can't work