Works very well. Interface is easy to use.

The function of this Add-On is difficult to automate because testing all those sites mechanically is going to set off countermeasures. Plus, where cookies have been deleted, the client is going to recognize gateway portals as a failure to load.

I give it 5 stars, but I do recommend that you implement check boxes for batch whitelisting because you're always going to get a lot of false positives.

Kudos.

EDIT: I just noticed the filter boxes at the top of the tree. You might still simplify whitelisting, or allow filtering entries as you go. Still, no redundancies or procedural anomalies. 5/5

Nice one

Finds fairly well all errors and duplicates but it's simply horrible trying to delete all of them. Uninstalling fro FF

Did what it said it would do and I had a lot of bookmarks to manage.

It's a decent tool and does a good job of finding dupes! But there're no mass commands or buttons to deal with the dupes in one shot but rather you have to sit there and manually click on every dupe checkbox to take action.

The Find Broken URLs is a good feature but many websites like linkedin, facebook that do not allow webscrapers, see it as a threat, causing Bookmarks Organizer to generate a false positive report that the bookmark is broken or dead. The average person using this add-on needs to see friendlier http errors such as "the target web url does not allow remote checking!" as opposed to http 404!

1. When a bookmark is in a subfolder of the bookmarks toolbar, the path is not displayed correctly.

2. Clearing broken bookmarks one by one is a pain. It's useful if you can put a check mark on a few and delete them all at once.

Developer: "I think I'll automate the collection of information, but make actually doing anything with it as hard as possible!"

You can't even tab to the button you want to push on the popup.

Windows 3 had a better UI than this.

It can't delete lump of all bookmarks found.
But I check them one by one, so it completely conforms with my use.

Clean nice gui, good for finding duplicates, but offers no possibility for mass deletion, which makes it a bit useless :-(

Seems almost deliberately slow and tedious, like the developer thinks we want to sit and manually remove 1,000 duplicates one at a time.

it finds the duplicates but has no button to delete them..

Fool proof duplicate and dead bookmark organizer ... with a huge BUT ... you have to confirm manually every single change to the corrections (redirect, delete, whitelist) ... and since its visual, you can't select the 'ok' by pressing space or arrows, ..... and this can quickly become very very annoying.
Please add an option to disable the confirmation box. thank you.

I know I've got a lot of bookmarks, but it is supposed to help me get rid of the dead ones and duplicates, so that is exactly what I want it to do.

But Firefox always crashes after about 4,000 are checked, 2,700 warnings and 300 errors.

So why, Mr Developer, don't you add the ability to select which folder of bookmarks to check? Or specify a number of bookmarks to check and then stop, so we can deal with some of the checked bookmarks before it crashes Firefox?

...just an idea.