it is so good (nearly perfect) Rated 4 out of 5 stars

love the crazy icon; great for when youtube seems to stutter, download then watch, delete or keep, you decide
. also has OGG support ogg/oga
[edit: wasn't able to do FULL HD with this video: https://youtu.be/5L-4ZrOk1Tc
but was able to with this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHP5MKgK0o8 ]
{not using 'beta'}
[edit: tried again with the 'beta' but same thing; it does all the downloading of video file and 2 audio track dls, and the final file plays but no audio and the play counter reads zero wherever it is on the timeline, using vlc]
{the oga did not work for the same video that did not work on FULL HD; the mp3 did work, the regular HD did work}
{oga did work for the other video that also worked on FULL HD, but it was a music video, not just the music, which surprised me, considering the a in the oga, curious}

This user has a previous review of this add-on.

Doesn't seem to work any longer - Use Beta Version Rated 5 out of 5 stars

I loved this addon, but it does not seem to work any longer. Using Firefox version 47.

Ok, the beta version linked to by the developer seems to work, though. Thanks!!!

Link to working version if anyone needs it: http://glimmersoft.com/podblog/2015/11/19/beta-version-up-at-addons-mozilla-org/

Perfecto Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Favor revisar la compatibilidad con la ultima version de firefox.

Maravilhoso Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Clicou baixou ,simples e muito eficaz .

Click to download Rated 5 out of 5 stars

When opening from below a video on YouTube - I've tried clicking all over but there's no visible button, not sure if this is the same issue that naykang reported earlier. Works from the firefox menu though but you can't use the clipping tool from there.

Edit: Thanks for the recommendation, the beta fixes this problem

Can you give the last beta a try?

See here for how to install:

http://glimmersoft.com/podblog/2015/11/19/beta-version-up-at-addons-mozilla-org/

I've been holding off on putting it online because some folks had problems the first time I put a version up that worked the way the beta does. It's been working for most folks, but I haven't gotten much feedback...

Burn CD'S Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Can you burn cd's with Youtube MP3 Podcaster?

great addon Rated 5 out of 5 stars

works if you dont have the older update, works really well.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Like the others, I noticed that it stopped working recently. It happens - FF changes something or YouTube changes something, and it takes some time for the addon to catch up. It's not as if they send out notices ahead of time, especially since YouTube would certainly prefer to make it impossible to download anything.

That said, the below suggestion to try the Developer Channel beta version was an excellent idea. I switched to that version, and the downloads showed back up upon restart. They're a little odd; the MP3 format downloaded the video and everything (which works okay, though it's weird to have an MP3 video), and the Full HD MP4 came out glitchy and truncated (which doesn't work, but the MP3 gave me video...) I tried renaming the extension to see if the MP3 video still works as an MP4, and so far it's fine. It's a bit roundabout, but maybe this detail will help refine the update.

A suggestion for future options - perhaps the clipping could be made to work at either end? There are frustrating videos with long silences at the end instead of the beginning, and it would be nice to be able to easily cut the dead air off.

This user has a previous review of this add-on.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

worked till a few days ago, then after the last mozilla update, the field of the add on is everytime blank. unable to download, unable to recognize anything, i'll give 5 stars when it works again

Not Working !!! Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Not working for me. In the dialog pops up, the download area is still blank. In the developper version, the links are here, but doesn't works. Impossible to download anything.

Can you give the last beta a try?

3.8.9b as of this writing. It should work so long as you're not on one of the "e10" (multi-process) builds/modes. If it doesn't send logs if you can :).

Only works with flash :( Rated 2 out of 5 stars

A shame this won't work without flash installed, when's the next version ?

Actually it should work without flash...

At least on youtube.com. I use plain HTML 5 on youtube. If you get a chance try the 3.8.8b beta (scroll to the bottom of the addon page and look for "Developer Channel") if you're having trouble. There's some issues with the Controls dialog right now. I've got it fixed on my test machines but I want to get some feedback before I try another launch since what works for me didn't work for everyone else in 3.8.6 :P.

THE REAL THING! Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Download Music in 256kbps. Search no further.. Wonderful . THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!

Stopped Working Rated 5 out of 5 stars

this morning, it stopped working...just get a blank.
however, still the best downloader ever...probably needs to be updated. thanks for this excellent downloader.

Can you give the last beta a try?

3.8.9b as of this writing. It should work so long as you're not on one of the "e10" (multi-process) builds/modes. If it doesn't send logs if you can :).

Cream of the Crop Rated 5 out of 5 stars

This is by far the best downloader to create MP3s that I have used. What makes it stand out is the clipping tool which is so easy and simple to use.

przestała działać Rated 2 out of 5 stars

wcześniej cudownie wszystko ściągała, dziś całkowicie nie działa...

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.8.6). 

Used to work great but now Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Not working for me. The dialog pops up as it should but now there are ads running along the top of the dialog box and where the download links are that whole area is now blank. The image for the download is present, the info about the vid is there on the left side but yea, no links to download. I've tried this with various vids to see if there is a change but all of a sudden no matter what vid I try I get that right side where the download links are supposed to be is now blank! Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!

Fixed in Dev channel

Found the issue (there was a change in how FF handles document references to the opening window). This is fixed in the development channel. You can install it from https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/ (it's at the very, very bottom of the page, click "Development Channel" to expand the section and you can install it). I'll have it in the mainline in a few weeks :).

Still in development but It's real good :D Rated 4 out of 5 stars

I real love this add since i try to put podcasts on my mp3player,but after a it wouldn't let me download them at all it's just straight blank.Maybe is just me begin silly but it has been an issue for me

Fixed in Dev channel

Found the issue (there was a change in how FF handles document references to the opening window). This is fixed in the development channel. You can install it from https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/ (it's at the very, very bottom of the page, click "Development Channel" to expand the section and you can install it). I'll have it in the mainline in a few weeks :).

Youtube MP3 Podcaster Rated 3 out of 5 stars

This would be the best add on if the panel came up to change the bit rate to 320kbps great work hopefully it gets fixed

This is a limitation of youtube :)

Hi, the reason I top out at 320kbps is that's currently the highest bit rate you'll see on youtube. The conversion software (ffmpeg) that makes the MP3 can't "increase" the bit rate from the original video/audio so even if we try setting it higher you still see the original bit rate :)

No longer works Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Gives me O bytes after download is finished. Is there a fix? Thanks, I have been using this for years.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.7.8). 

3.7.8 should have fixed this

Can you uninstall/reinstall and if that doesn't fix it out right send me some logs? See here for how: http://glimmersoft.com/podblog/youtube-mp3-podcaster-logging/

Working perfectly again Rated 5 out of 5 stars

The latest version fixes the 0 sized file issue a lot of us have been having on FF 42.

Thank you Jeremy for making this plugin and for your continued development on it.

I tried about 5 other plugins and this is by far the best one for downloading video and audio.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.7.8).