Love the idea, but the execution's faulty Rated 1 out of 5 stars

I wish I could, but I cannot leave a glowing recommendation based on the idea alone, no matter how lovely the idea is. The addon just doesn't work. It replaces the adds alright, but with one-color squares, which is not exactly it's job (unless contemporary artists have gotten lazier). I cannot add any new subscription, and I cannot download neither of the default ones. When I found out about the add-on by the magnificent Steve, I switched back to firefox just to be able to use it, now it seems I have to go back to chrome or safari. Sad.

Edit:
Dear Steve, I got it from here. If you don't want people to download add ons they have every right to think are legitimately working, then don't publish them. I see that you've changed that now, which is great.

That all being said, I'd love to come back when the final version is released, and leave a 5 star review, because, like I said, I absolutely love the idea.

Good luck with your add-on!

That's because it's not released yet

The new version isn't publicly released yet. The version on this site is from 2011. If you have a version that works, you probably found it through a link that says it's a beta release.

This review will drag down the average on something I've stated isn't done. I'm glad you think I am magnificent, but I'd like a chance to finish the new release before you give a 1 star review.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars

I tried it it worked ok, but I thought of a few possibilities that could either make it better or be another add-on entirely. 1) Include a menu like 'Personas' to select the style of art. For example: checking a box for sculptures, abstract sculptures, abstract paintings, fine art oils, fine art water colors, pop art retro, pop art modern, graffiti retro, graffiti modern, ceramics etc. 2) Enable the ability of user image files to rotate or cycle through by time or next command. Any option to individualize use of your add-on would improve and validate it's value- TY

Needed a "click to load" function to use it like clickable placeholders !!! Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Would you please to implement an option to load and show the original Ad by a click on image ?
It would be great to use it like a "flashblock"- replacement and for images and media too !!!

Thank you in advance!

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.52). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Works fine!

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.51). 

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Ok. so this is not my program but i have an opinion. If your going to make a program that is often going to be used to bock images of women and men wearing close to no clothes if any you shouldn't put art of people with no clothes. There are better ways to create a platform for people to experience art. if you want to preview what you will be in for before you add this program check this link.
This is not something children should see. Its a graphic image so don't check it if you don't want to be exposed to naked people art.
the link below is the original addart link
chrome://addart/skin/5artbanner300x600.jpg
The one below here is in case they decide to change the url of the image because of this message.
http://tinypic.com/r/ivd7x0/6

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.5). 

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Not sure if this has turned into some sort of joke add on because it used to work perfectly fine. I find the some of the images disturbing (woman and man probing a decapitated persons head) My primary reason for getting this was to protect my little sisters from the occasional disturbing image not to make sure they were subjected to such things. Dont get me wrong this was a great add on about a year ago when images were replaced by art. 0* if i could but 1* will have to do.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.5). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Ha Ha Ha!!! It works, this is very cool guys your efforts have paid off. I thought I had missed something when I got curious about this one picture that didn't fit "It Was Ad Art" 5 stars all day long!!!!!

Thank You!!

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.5). 

add-art porn Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Yeah, the sick porn and bondage scenes have showed up on my art add-on today also. I have now uninstalled. WTH? I tried to find an email to alert someone at firefox but cannot find one.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

this is fixed

We have this fixed, please see this forum thread for more:
http://forum.add-art.org/topic/bondage-pics-in-add-art-1229

Porn add art Rated 1 out of 5 stars

I can't believe that without warning pornographic images have been loaded onto my comptuer. Why isn't there a choice? For goodness sakes not all of us want to look at cocks or gay bondage. I thought images like that had to be on "adult" sites. What about parents that haven't seen what these images are? You could get people into big trouble for what you've slipped into this. And just one more thing..why should I have to give this a rating? Isn't there "heck no I don't want to rate this button?" The rating of the porn is over the top don't you think?

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

This is fixed

We have this fixed, please see this forum thread for more:
http://forum.add-art.org/topic/bondage-pics-in-add-art-1229

Brilliant! Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Brilliant! Replacing resource-hogging ads with contemporary art has to be the most beautiful, generous, and ingenious functionality to be offered as an option to enhance ones web browsing experience. I feel the fundamental idea of Add-Art is really an artwork all on its own. In fact, on a few occasions, I could honestly say the idea of Add-Art was more interesting than the work it was exhibiting at the time. Add-Art is essentially fostering opportunities to expose the masses to contemporary artwork by hosting digital exhibitions in spaces which were once occupied by less intellectual, and sometimes malicious, content: web ads. Anyhow, the idea of this add-on alone deserves praise, recognition and support. Shame on those that are giving this a bad rating just because they didn't like the exhibition that was up at whatever point in time they used it. If you don't like the work, it is not the programs fault. As previously noted, I see the exhibitions to be secondary in importance when compared to the fundamental concept of replacing something annoying and/or malicious with something thoughtful, intelligent, and maybe even beautiful. So, if the current exhibition is not inline with your aesthetics, then please be aware that is only YOUR opinion, which ultimately has nothing to do with the effectiveness or functionality of the add-on in regards to the intended purpose of the rating system which hosts this review. So to keep things fair and honest and to perpetuate peace, love and happiness in strange places such as this add-on review site, I might suggest that if you hate the current show, don't rate the add-on based on your criticism of the current work, please. You can express your opinions about art on a blog or forum, you can turn Add-Art off for a couple weeks until new work is uploaded, or better yet, you can look at the show every day and attempt to articulate why you don't like the work, why someone else might love the work, and maybe even identify ways to make the work stronger so you can make your own art and one-up that artist whose work you hated so much you ALMOST gave Add-Art a bad review, right before you read my post and came to your senses. On an semi-related note which is specifically responding to the review about "inappropriate content", if you can identify "inappropriate content" within an artwork I am compelled to believe your idea of art is not on the same page as that of the Add-Art Team's, or even the contemporary art world as as a whole, for that matter. Art can be whatever an artist wants. Art doesn't like rules and doesn't care what is appropriate under whatever circumstances you might find it offensive. In fact, offensive art is usually more successful than non-offensive. If its is a "family" sense of appropriateness you are referring to, art will always let you down so take your family to the zoo and skip the art museum. Maybe your idea of art is Thomas Kinkade or watercolor seascapes by that guy on PBS? If that's what going on, still stick with the zoo. The mall will have your Kinkades but you might have to cover your children's eyes when walking past Abercrombie or Victoria Secrets.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

Thanks

This made me smile.

For the most part I agree. I feel it's important to give artists and curators as much freedom as possible. I feel this freedom is more important than trying to satisfy an audience, which has proved to be impossible - someone has complained about and/or complimented nearly every show. As a guideline we tell artists there's a very broad and massive audience and that the plugin is installed in public schools. As I have mentioned before, for the most part this has worked and only one time have we had to intervene.

Our goal is not to provide pleasing images. That said, it's not to upset people either. The goal is to create a new and interesting venue for contemporary art and to present it to audiences that would normally not see it.

I could go on too long, so let me direct people who would like to discuss to our forum at http://forum.add-art.org or feel free to contact us directly at info at add-art.org

Thanks again for the words of support.

NSFW! Rated 1 out of 5 stars

I mentioned this in an earlier review, and just as I thought, It went to nudity. I'm scrambling to remove the images from my computer and hoping my Boss doesn't run an audit of my machine. I gave it a shot, and now have it uninstalled and will not recommend.

Dear developer,

make a gallery of art similar to the one personas delivers. make sure to make a NSFW category, so that users do not have to explain why pornographic images were on their computer.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

SFW

The images you mentioned were not supposed to be released and won't happen again. (see comment below for more.)

We are working on allowing people to create and subscribe to feeds of art. We're all volunteers so it will take some time. If anyone wants to help code, it's open source and we'd love your contributions.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars

Great idea for an add-on, and the delivery keeps getting better. Just don't expect too much from the "art." I thought the nods to 350.org were a little much (and just another kind of ad), but the current set of kaleidoscoped gay bondage porn and post-coital genitals are definitely over the NSFW line. Don't get me wrong--I'm no prude--but come on.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

shouldn't have been released

The images you mentioned were not supposed to be released and won't happen again. Our policy with the add-on was that the artists and curators decide what is appropriate. For almost 2 years this worked. With this show we decided to draw a line. But there was some confusion as the discussion went right up to the last minute. That work went live for just under 2 hours in error. We fixed it. All I can say is it wont happen again. And apologies to anyone who happened to download in that time.

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

Great presentation, coupled with incompetent content.

Really, what workplace environment do you think would find the current set of hi-res penis photos Safe for Work?

Try to find less sophomoric "curators" to assemble your collections - - you're driving users away for obviously inappropriate content.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Add-art keeps on giving. There are loads of images and they are updated frequently - meaning you never get bored. I would recommend this to everyone who is already fed up with ads, and everyone with the slightest interest in contemporary art.
5/5 Go-on-ya!

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.4). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Highly recommended. This project is supported by Rhizome and Eyebeam, two arts organizations who's aim is to create new dialogue and outlets for contemporary art.

Overall, excellent complement to AdBlock Plus.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.3). 

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

I quite love this. It is wonderful to have art replacing ads. How could one complain? Well... though I am not complaining - some might. Without getting into what "art" constitutes some might consider the content to not be "safe for work" While browsing recently I was presented with something fairly suggestive. I just think users should know this before installing. Here is the example of this: http://stashbox.org/675375/oopsart.png

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.3). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

This is the best complement with AdBlock Plus =)

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.3). 

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

This is a great idea but it does take up a large amount of memory space and the art that I've seen is MEH, at best. I have yet to see a piece that interested me.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.3). 

we provide a platform, we can't account for taste.

We provide a platform for contemporary art curators. Different people like different art, but hopefully it's all better than someone trying to sell you products you didn't ask for.

Great Add-on But Too Big In Size Rated 5 out of 5 stars

I'll give it a 5 for the idea the fact it works. But 7000 kb? That's one of the largest sized add-ons out there. This shouldn't be more than 700 kb tops and that's with Adblock Plus. The idea is to replace ads with pictures not make a whole art show while slowing down browsing in the process.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.3). 

That includes the jpgs

That size includes the jpgs. We've noticed no difference in browser speed. The code is actually pretty small. If you have suggestions, or would like to contribute improvements, please contact us.

quick question... Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Does this work in combination with the add-on NoScript? Could anyone tell mee?

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (0.8.2). 

don't think so

we've heard reports no script and add-art don't play well together for some reason.