Almost perfect go-to theme Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Despite what SOME people might say, brown is a fine color for themes, and I'm actually here looking for a nice brown tonight. (Not "walnut" theme.) PitchDark is less brown and more dark taupe, anyway. It's a matter of preference, but saying something should "always" or "never" be something is daft.
This is a great theme, more complete than others, but as other reviewers have mentioned, it could use a little more personalization in the buttons and links. I'd love to see this theme done in other dark, rich colorways, starting with something of a true woody/milk-chocolatey brown, maybe with orange or gold buttons/accents; deep blues, red, green - this theme would look great wearing any colors.
Overall, I love it and it's my most used theme.