Star Icon Sucks! Rated 3 out of 5 stars

Great theme except for the icon for the star for starred mail items. What the hell is that? Sorry, I just can't stand it. If the star icon looked like a star, the theme would be a whole world better.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.33). 

I don't understand which icon you mean. You can send me an email (look on my web site) with screen captures to show me exactly what do you mean (and compare with default theme or an other). For the "starred" items I find in the theme, I think my icon choice is quite good. But may be you don't speak of the same one.