Looks great Bewertet mit 4 von 5 Sternen

von mcdavis am June 7, 2007 · Permanentlink

Review of Vista-Aero Theme
Thursday, June 07, 2007

First Reactions:
Wow! Like it a lot.

Lots of custom bindings to give the UI an IE7 appearance. I bet IE users looking at Firefox will really appreciate that.

Sets window and dialog background colors to match the rest of the theme, which is nice (not all themes do this).

Handles all toolbar modes: big/small icons, text+icons/icons only/text only, normal/fullscreen (but not the FullerScreen extension).

IE7-style additions take up space in the toolbar that I might end up missing. IE7 users might not mind, but I might look into disabling them with userChrome.css

Would like a statement from the submitter stating that they hold all IP for the icons (and specifically that they're not copied out of the Vista/IE7 UI).

In large icon mode, the phishing warning (safe browsing) icon scales too tall. The close button on the safe browsing popup is cropped off on the right edge.

BUG: Bindings put Bookmarks and History buttons on all sidebar headers, but you really only want them on sidebar headers that occur in the main browser window. For example, they also appear on the Help window (where they don't even work) and in the middle sidebar of the Sage extension, where they duplicate themselves from the top header of Sage.

Correctly glows for new tab.
The browser tabs are confusing me a little. I wish there was more distinction between current and other tabs.

Overall, this is an excellent theme and with a couple fixes will be rock-solid. Nice job, developers.